Download E-books Poetics before Plato: Interpretation and Authority in Early Greek Theories of Poetry PDF

By Grace M. Ledbetter

Combining literary and philosophical research, this research defends an totally cutting edge interpreting of the early historical past of poetics. it's the first to argue that there's a distinctively Socratic view of poetry and the 1st to attach the Socratic view of poetry with prior literary tradition.

Literary conception is mostly acknowledged firstly Plato's recognized critique of poetry within the Republic. Grace Ledbetter demanding situations this entrenched assumption through arguing that Plato's prior dialogues Ion, Protagoras, and Apology introduce a distinctively Socratic concept of poetry that responds polemically to standard poets as rival theorists. Ledbetter tracks the assets of this Socratic reaction by means of introducing separate readings of the poetics implicit within the poetry of Homer, Hesiod, and Pindar. studying those poets' theories from a brand new attitude that uncovers their literary, rhetorical, and political goals, she demonstrates their decisive impact on Socratic wondering poetry.

The Socratic poetics Ledbetter elucidates focuses now not on censorship, yet at the interpretation of poetry as a resource of ethical knowledge. This philosophical method of reading poetry stands at odds with the poets' personal theories--and with the Sophists' remedy of poetry. not like the Republic's specialise in exposing and banishing poetry's irrational and necessarily corrupting impact, Socrates' concept contains poetry as material for philosophical inquiry inside of an tested life.

Reaching again into what has too lengthy been thought of literary theory's prehistory, Ledbetter advances arguments that might redefine how classicists, philosophers, and literary theorists take into consideration Plato's poetics.

Show description

Read or Download Poetics before Plato: Interpretation and Authority in Early Greek Theories of Poetry PDF

Similar Literary Criticism books

The Art of Language Invention: From Horse-Lords to Dark Elves, the Words Behind World-Building

An insider’s travel during the development of invented languages from the bestselling writer and author of languages for the HBO sequence video game of Thrones and the Syfy sequence DefianceFrom grasp language writer David J. Peterson comes an inventive advisor to language development for sci-fi and delusion lovers, writers, video game creators, and language enthusiasts.

After Babel: Aspects of Language and Translation

Whilst it first seemed in 1975, After Babel created a sensation, quick developing itself as either a arguable and seminal research of literary thought. within the unique version, Steiner supplied readers with the 1st systematic research because the eighteenth century of the phenomenology and procedures of translation either within and among languages.

Is the Rectum a Grave?: and Other Essays

Over the process a unusual profession, critic Leo Bersani has tackled various matters in his writing, and this assortment gathers jointly a few of his most interesting paintings. starting with one of many foundations of queer theory—his well-known meditation on how intercourse ends up in a shattering of the self, “Is the Rectum a Grave?

The Rhetoric of Fiction

The 1st variation of The Rhetoric of Fiction remodeled the feedback of fiction and shortly grew to become a vintage within the box. probably the most established texts in fiction classes, it's a common reference aspect in complex discussions of the way fictional shape works, how authors make novels obtainable, and the way readers recreate texts, and its recommendations and terms—such as "the implied author," "the postulated reader," and "the unreliable narrator"—have develop into a part of the traditional serious lexicon.

Additional resources for Poetics before Plato: Interpretation and Authority in Early Greek Theories of Poetry

Show sample text content

It truly is transparent that Socrates’ idea of poetic proposal is appropriate with the excellence we famous with regards to the rhapsode: Ion’s profitable functionality of Homer is dependent upon his wisdom of the verse and on his place at the similar chain of proposal that connects Homer to the inspiration. The query continues to be of the way accurately to signify a similar contrast for poets. One present solution proposes that concept contributes no longer what's actual or clever in poetry, yet in simple terms what's aesthetically helpful or relocating. 25 This view does justice to the truth that Socrates turns out to limit idea to explaining superhuman excellence in human construction, however it can't account for one more characteristic of Socrates’ view. in keeping with the Socratic concept, basically poets are encouraged. Sculptors, flute gamers, painters, and others who fulfill the trendy belief of an artist are excluded from proposal; their arts are technai. 26 yet Socrates indicates no it's because the paintings of sculptors and painters can't be aesthetically appealing, and certainly, it might be unreasonable to exclude them from having such attractiveness. 25 26 See Janaway 1995, ch. 1, esp. pp. 33 – 35. 532e–533b (technên, 532e4). ninety bankruptcy 4 within the Socratic thought, then, idea doesn't give a contribution to poetry’s in simple terms aesthetic worth. This element is essential for knowing that Socrates’ curiosity within the Ion and somewhere else isn't aesthetics typically, yet particular to poetry and its exact connection to the divine. For a solution to the query of what component idea does give a contribution to the poet we needs to glance to the Apology’s therapy of poetry, to which we will flip almost immediately. ahead of doing that, we have to give some thought to Socrates’ identity of suggestion with a kingdom of “possession. ” this selection of Socrates’ concept within the Ion offers his purpose for denying that these proficient with concept have wisdom, and hence additionally the Ion’s basic explanation for rejecting the Homeric view that proposal confers divine wisdom: For a poet is an ethereal factor, winged and holy, and he's not capable of make poetry until eventually he turns into encouraged and is going out of his brain and his mind isn't any longer in him. so long as a man or woman has his mind in his ownership he'll consistently lack the ability to make poetry or sing prophesy. (534b3–7) not just is highbrow mastery no longer useful for poets, however the present of notion is incompatible with the poet’s being in any respect engaged intellectually. because the Ion offers this account of concept, the poet is completely passive whilst he appears to be like so much inventive: The god takes their mind away . . . in order that we who listen should still comprehend that they're no longer those who communicate these verses which are of such excessive price, for his or her mind isn't really in them: the god himself is the one that speaks, . . . (534c7–d4) Like prophets or oracles, the poet doesn't writer his poetry; he's not the speaker of the verse that the inspiration sings together with his voice. The poet, then, contributes little greater than amplification to an inaudible divine sign.

Rated 4.68 of 5 – based on 31 votes